Home / Catering
South Orange, NJ · Essex/Union/Morris

Catering in South Orange, NJ

Parties, events, offices — we cater from the same 4th-generation kitchen that's been feeding South Orange since 1933. Thin & crispy "bar pie" pizza, wings, entrees, and the full table. Request a quote or call 973-763-1377.

Delivery
The Catering Menu

The Same Menu, for the Table

Build your catering order from the full Bunny's menu — "bar pie" pizza, 9 wing flavors, entrees, burgers, sandwiches, salads, and sides. Tell us the headcount and we'll take it from there.

Appetizers

  • Bang-Bang Shrimp15.95
  • Battered Avocado Slices10.95
  • Beer-Battered Mushrooms9.95
  • Bruschetta10.95
  • Cheddar Cheese Jalapeño Poppers12.95
  • Chicken Fingers10.95
  • Chicken Fingers — Buffalo Style12.95
  • Fried Calamari15.95
    Hot or Sweet
  • Fried Pickles9.95
  • Garlic Bread5.25
  • Garlic Bread + Cheese6.50
  • Garlic Shrimp + Toast18.95
  • Grilled Eggplant + Garlic Toast14.95
    Balsamic Glaze + Roasted Peppers + choice of Fresh Mozzarella OR Goat Cheese
  • Hot Honey Cheese Bites10.95
  • Mozzarella Sticks9.95
  • Overloaded Nachos15.95
    Cheese + Chili + Lettuce + Olives + Onions + Tomato + Salsa + Sour Cream
  • Potato Skins12.95
    Bacon + Cheddar Cheese
  • Quesadilla El Capitan15.95
    Chicken + Lemon + Spinach
  • Quesadilla South of the Border15.95
    Cheddar Cheese + Chili + Onion + Tomato
  • Zucchini Sticks9.95
    + Horseradish Sauce

Fries

  • French Fries6.95
  • Garlic Parmesan Fries10.95
  • Lava Fries15.95
    Bacon + Cheese + Hot Sauce
  • Old Bay Fries10.95
  • Spicy Curly Fries9.95
  • Spicy Curly Fries + Mozzarella Cheese + Gravy12.95
  • Sweet Potato Fries8.95
  • Waffle Fries9.95

Wings

12.95

All wings $12.95. Buffalo served with DEFCON Sauces: #1 Extreme / #2 Medium / #3 Mild.

  • BBQ12.95
  • Buffalo12.95
    DEFCON Sauces: #1 Extreme / #2 Medium / #3 Mild
  • Garlic Parmesan12.95
  • Honey BBQ12.95
  • Korean BBQ12.95
  • Lemon Pepper12.95
  • Old Bay12.95
  • Old Bay Hot Honey12.95
  • Scampi12.95

Salad + Soup

Bang-Bang Shrimp or Blackened Shrimp or Grilled Shrimp added to any salad + $7.

  • Antipasto15.95
  • Caesar10.95
  • Caesar + Grilled Chicken15.95
  • The Garlic Salad15.95
  • The Garlic Salad + Cranberries + Goat Cheese18.95
  • The Garlic Salad + Grilled Chicken18.95
  • The Garlic Salad + The Works22.95
  • Iceberg Wedge12.95
    Bacon + Bleu Cheese + Tomato
  • Kale Garlic22.95
    Arugula + Berries + Chicken + Corn + Peppers
  • Mike's Defcon Garlic Salad22.95
    Choose Your Heat OR served w/ DEFCON #3; Avocado or Crumbled Bleu Cheese + Crispy Boneless Chicken OR Gluten Free Grilled Chicken + Bleu Cheese Dressing on Side
  • Sabino18.95
    Aged Provolone + Fresh Mozzarella + Fresh Roasted Peppers + Iceberg Lettuce + Olives + Onion + Salami + Oil + Vinegar
  • Taco Salad13.95
  • Tossed8.95
  • Bowl of Chili12.95
    Cheese + Onions (+ Sour Cream upon request)
  • Homemade Soup of the Day5.95

Entrees

  • Angel Hair Pasta18.95
    Fresh Basil + Goat Cheese + Grape Tomato
  • Calamari Fried or Sautéed20.95
    Hot or Sweet + Choice of Pasta
  • Cavatelli + Broccoli15.95
  • Chicken Francese22.95
    + Fettuccine Alfredo
  • Chicken Parmigiana20.95
    + Choice of Pasta
  • Chicken Parmesan Vodka Sauce + Penne Vodka Sauce26.95
  • Chicken or Sausage Murphy20.95
    Sweet or Spicy; Mushroom + Onion + Peppers + Potato
  • Chicken + Sausage Murphy23.95
    Sweet or Spicy; Mushroom + Onion + Peppers + Potato
  • Chicken Scampi20.95
    + Choice of Pasta
  • Eggplant Parmigiana17.95
    + Choice of Pasta
  • Eggplant Rollatini18.95
    + Choice of Pasta
  • Fettuccine or Tortellini Alfredo18.95
  • Noelle's Pick21.95
    Angel Hair Pasta + Artichoke + Asparagus + Goat Cheese + Spinach
  • Penne Vodka16.95
    Meatball OR Sausage
  • Ravioli Homemade17.95
    Meatball OR Sausage
  • Ravioli Vodka Sauce19.95
    Sweet or Spicy + Meatballs or Sausage
  • Ryan's Pick23.95
    Spicy Upon Request; Penne Vodka + Chicken + Sausage
  • Shrimp Fra Diavlo or Scampi24.95
    Linguini
  • Spaghetti12.95
    Meatball OR Sausage
  • Spicy Tortellini18.95
  • Three Cheese Baked Ziti17.95
    Meatball OR Sausage

Burgers

Add-ons (each): Peppers / Sautéed Mushroom / Sautéed Onion $1.00; Bacon $3.00.

  • Brittany's Pick Burger or Chicken17.95
    Avocado + Bacon + Lettuce + Onion + Tomato + Sweet Potato Fries
  • Defcon Bacon Burger17.95
    Bleu Cheese + Onion Rings + Side of DEFCON Sauce (Choose Your Heat)
  • The Famous Monster Burger15.95
    Cheddar Cheese + French Fries + Lettuce + Mushroom + Sautéed Onion + Peppers + Hot Peppers + Salsa + Sour Cream + Tomato
  • Michelangelo's Turkey Burger15.95
    Cheddar Cheese + Sautéed Mushroom + Onion On Whole Wheat Bun + Sweet Potato Fries
  • Papa's Roni Burger15.95
    Marinara + Mozzarella + Pepperoni + French Fries
  • 1/4 Pound Fresh Burger12.95
    Lettuce + Tomato + Potato Chips
  • 1/4 Pound Fresh Burger + Cheese13.95
    American / Bleu / Cheddar / Mozzarella / Provolone / Swiss / Pizza Burger
  • 1/4 Pound Fresh Burger + French Fries13.95

Sandwiches

Served w/ Potato Chips. Add Bacon or French Fries + $3.00 each.

  • BLT15.95
    + Sweet Potato Fries
  • Broccoli Rabe + Chicken or Sausage17.95
    Peppers + Grilled Onion On Garlic Bread
  • Cheesesteak on Garlic Bread15.95
    Mushrooms + Fried Onions + Peppers
  • Chicken Parmagiana16.95
  • Chili Cheese Dogs (2)14.95
  • Double Italian Hot Dog13.95
    Onions + Fresh Peppers + Potatoes + Sauce (Optional)
  • Double Italian Sausage13.95
    Onions + Fresh Peppers + Potatoes + Sauce (Optional)
  • Eggplant Parmagiana13.95
  • Grilled Chicken13.95
    Honey Mustard OR Mayo
  • Grilled Chicken + Peppers15.95
    Fresh Roasted Peppers + Fresh Mozzarella + Balsamic Vinegar
  • Kop Chicken Cutlet17.95
    Bacon + Cheese + Lettuce + Onion + Ranch + Tomato + French Fries + Parmigiana
  • Meatball or Sausage Parmagiana10.95
  • Ryan's Slamm'in Sub13.95
    Ham + Lettuce + Onions + Pepperoni + Peppers + Provolone + Salami + Tomato + Turkey + Oil + Vinegar
  • Turkey Club13.95

Kid's Menu

12 and under.

  • Brodey's Mac + Cheese7.95
  • Chicken Fingers + French Fries6.95
  • Hot Dog + French Fries6.95
  • Kid's Penne7.95
    Meatball OR Sausage
  • Kid's Spaghetti7.95
    Meatball OR Sausage
  • Kid's Grilled Cheese + French Fries6.95

Sides

8.95

$8.95 each. Sautéed or steamed.

  • Arugula8.95
  • Broccoli / Broccoli Rabe8.95
  • Kale8.95
  • Spinach8.95

Bunny's Famous Thin & Crispy Crust "Bar Pie" Style Pizza

Thin & crispy crust "bar pie" style, unless noted otherwise. Small serves 1; Large serves 2–3.

  • Bunny's Famous12 / 15
    Thin + crispy crust cheese pizza
  • Bunny's Tomato + Toppings Inverted12 / 15
    Cheese on the bottom, topped with fresh Jersey tomato sauce
  • Buffalo Chicken16.95 / 22.95
    Bleu cheese + spicy sauce + white meat chicken
  • Drunken Nonie Pie17.50 / 23.50
    Vodka sauce + ricotta cheese + prepared thin and crispy
  • Holy Pie Father Andrew's Special17.50 / 23.50
    Nonie pie + pesto + sausage + prepared thin and crispy
  • Honey-Roni15 / 20
    Pepperoni + hot honey + prepared thin and crispy
  • Large "Double Dough"17.50
  • Mexican Pie18.95 / 24.95
    Black olive + cheddar + chili + hot peppers + lettuce + mozzarella + onion + tomato + salsa + sour cream
  • Monster Extra Crispy20.95 / 26.95
    Cheddar + hot peppers + meatball + mozzarella + mushroom + onion + salsa/sour cream on side
  • Paradise21.95 / 27.95
    Alfredo sauce + bacon + chicken + mozzarella + mushroom + provolone + spinach + tomato
  • The Works22.95 / 28.95
    All classic toppings — with or without anchovies
  • Toni L Nil Drunken Nonie22.95 / 28.95
    Pepperoni + pesto + ricotta + vodka sauce + prepared thin and crispy
  • Calzone14.95
    Classic toppings +$3.00 ea; Gourmet toppings +$4.00 ea
  • Pizza Roll13
    Classic toppings +$2.50 ea; Gourmet toppings +$3.00 ea
  • Large Pie and Brew25.95

Classic Toppings

1.50 / 2.50 (per item, sm/lg)

Meatball / Mushroom / Black Olive / Onion / Pepperoni / Hot Honey / Hot Peppers / Fresh Roasted Peppers / Salami / Sausage / Tomato

Gourmet Toppings

2 / 4 (per item, sm/lg)

Bacon / Fresh Basil / Cheddar Cheese / Chicken / Clams / Fresh Eggplant / Fresh Garlic / Goat Cheese / Fresh Mushroom / Pesto / Fresh Pineapple / Ricotta Cheese / Baby Shrimp / Fresh Spinach / Sun-Dried Tomato / Baked Ziti / Vodka Sauce

Dessert

7

$7 each. Ask for availability and details.

  • Apple Pie a la Mode7
  • Alexa's Brownie a la Mode7
  • Ella's Cookie Pie a la Mode7
  • Cheesecake7
  • Fried Cheesecake7
  • Ice Cream Sundae7

Champagne + Wine

Ask for availability and pricing.

  • Prosecco (Champagne)
  • Wine Red: Cabernet / Malbec / Merlot / Pinot Noir / Port / Opichi Chianti
  • Wine Rosé: Chateau d'Esclans Whispering Angel
  • Wine White: Robert Mondavi Chablis / Chardonnay / Pinot Grigio / Sauvignon Blanc / White Zinfandel

Cocktails + Seasonal Drinks

Cocktails $15 (select $20). High Noon hard seltzers $8.

  • Chocolate Martini15
  • Cranberry Margarita15
  • Cranberry Refresher15
  • Espresso Martini15
  • Hot Honey Margarita15
  • Hot Toddy15
  • Irish Coffee15
  • Spicy Margarita15
  • Bailey's Hot Chocolate20
  • Thin Mint Martini20
    Bailey's + peppermint schnapps + vodka
  • High Noon Hard Seltzer: Lime + Tequila8
    Tequila + real fruit juice + sparkling water; gluten free, no added sugar
  • High Noon Hard Seltzer: Peach + Vodka8
    Vodka + real fruit juice + sparkling water; gluten free, no added sugar
  • High Noon Hard Seltzer: Watermelon + Vodka8
    Vodka + real fruit juice + sparkling water; gluten free, no added sugar

Beer

On tap + bottled/canned. Ask for availability and pricing.

  • On Tap: Angry Orchard / Blue Moon / Coors Light / Dogfish Head 60 Minute IPA / Fat Tire Ale / Guinness / Sierra Nevada Little Hazy IPA / Sweet Water 420 IPA / Yuengling Lager / Seasonal
  • Bottled + Canned: Amstel Light / Brooklyn Lager / Bud / Bud Light / Carlsberg Pilsner / Corona / Corona Light / Dogfish Head Seaquench Ale (canned) / Dogfish Head Grateful Dead Juicy Pale Ale (canned) / Goose Island IPA / Heineken / Heineken Light / Heineken 0.0 / Hoegaarden / Michelob Ultra / Miller Lite / Miller High Life / Modelo / Molson Canadian / Newcastle / Pacifico / Pirate Pilsner (canned) / Pirate Plank IPA (canned) / Red Stripe / Rolling Rock / Sierra Nevada Torpedo / Soma Two Towns (canned) / Soma Dockside Hazy IPA (canned) / Stella Artois / Twisted Tea Half + Half / Twisted Tea Light / UFO / Voodoo IPA (canned) / Voodoo IPA Juicy Hazy IPA (canned) / Voodoo IPA Juice Force IPA (canned) / White Claw Spiked Seltzer (canned)

18% gratuity added to parties of 5 or more. Tell us the headcount and we'll build the order around it.

Request a Quote
Catering FAQ

Questions, answered

Still have questions? Call us — a real person picks up.

South Orange and the surrounding Essex/Union/Morris area — Maplewood, Millburn, Montclair, Orange, Vauxhall, and nearby. Tell us the location and we'll confirm.

The sooner the better for big events. For orders needed within 24 hours, call 973-763-1377 directly and we'll take it.

Yes — office lunches, team events, and parties. We'll build the order around your headcount and budget.

Let's feed your next event.

Request a quote or call 973-763-1377.